An Interactive Guide to the Top 5 Neighborhoods of Mystic Waterfront Real Estate
Mystic’s unique blend of historic New England charm and modern coastal luxury creates one of the region’s most desirable and competitive waterfront real estate markets. This guide provides an interactive look at the five most distinctive communities, comparing their lifestyle, views, water access, and pricing to help you find your perfect seaside home.
Median Mystic Home Price
$565K – $730K
Waterfront Properties Start At
$1.2M+
Neighborhood Comparison Overview
Use this dashboard to get a high-level comparison of the top waterfront neighborhoods. The chart below visualizes the typical price ranges, while the table summarizes the key lifestyle features of each area.
| Neighborhood | Vibe | Typical View | Water Access |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Downtown Mystic |
Vibrant & Walkable |
Panoramic views of the Mystic River, drawbridge, and bustling maritime activity. |
Excellent public access via parks and docks. |
|
Mason’s Island |
Exclusive & Private |
Sweeping, highly desirable views of Fishers Island Sound and Quiambaug Cove. |
Superior private access. |
|
West Mystic / Captain’s Row |
Quiet & Residential |
Serene views overlooking the Mystic River and its marinas. |
Good private access options, including private moorings and smaller residential docks. |
|
Stonington Borough |
Historic & Picturesque |
Stunning views of Stonington Harbor, the Sound, and the historic lighthouse. |
Excellent direct harbor access, often with private deep-water docks and proximity to duBois Beach. |
|
Noank / Groton Long Point |
Classic Coastal & Community-Focused |
Open water views of Fishers Island Sound. |
Focus on Sound access with marinas, private community beaches, and excellent boating. |